Most HOAs require homeowners to get approval before making visible exterior changes to their property — a new fence, a repaint, a deck, landscaping changes, or a new roof. This process usually runs through an Architectural Review Committee (ARC), sometimes called a Design Review Committee or Modifications Committee, a small group (often board members or dedicated volunteers) that reviews requests against the community's design guidelines.
What typically requires approval
- Exterior paint colors or siding changes
- Fences, walls, and gates
- Decks, patios, and pergolas
- Roofing material or color changes
- Landscaping changes visible from the street (major hardscaping, tree removal)
- Exterior lighting, solar panels, and satellite dishes
- Window and door replacements that change the exterior appearance
Interior changes almost never require ARC approval — the review process is specifically about anything visible from outside the home that could affect the community's overall look.
How the process usually works
- Submit an application — typically a form describing the project, plus supporting materials like photos, contractor plans, material samples, or paint swatches.
- Committee review — the ARC evaluates the request against the community's written design guidelines, not personal preference (though in practice, subjectivity does creep in).
- Decision within a set timeframe — many governing documents specify a response window (commonly 30-45 days); if the ARC doesn't respond in time, some states or governing documents treat that as automatic approval, though this varies.
- Written approval or denial — you should always get the decision in writing, and if denied, a reason. Save this regardless of outcome.
Common reasons projects get rejected
- Color or material doesn't match the approved palette in the design guidelines
- Incomplete application — missing plans, dimensions, or material specs
- Project doesn't meet setback or height requirements
- Precedent concerns — the ARC worries approving one request will force them to approve similar future ones they don't want
How to improve your odds
- Read the actual design guidelines before applying, not just the CC&Rs — most associations have a separate, more detailed architectural standards document.
- Submit complete applications the first time — photos, measurements, material/color samples, contractor info.
- Talk informally with the management company or a board member beforehand if you're unsure — many committees are happy to give informal guidance before a formal submission.
- Never start work before written approval, even if you're confident it'll be approved — this is one of the most common (and expensive) mistakes, since associations can require you to undo unapproved work at your own cost.
Denied and disagree? Most governing documents include an appeal process to the full board. If that doesn't resolve it, see our guide on how to fight an HOA fine for the broader dispute process, which applies similarly here.
This article is for general education and isn't legal advice. Architectural review timelines and default-approval rules vary by state and by each community's governing documents.
Related: Solar panels & EV chargers · How to fight an HOA fine